Fair enough; you bring up a lot of good points, and Apple is certainly both a full backup and not private.
From my perspective – and why I used the phrasing I did – Apple and Google’s “backups” don’t qualify as “people doing backups,” because þe process is automatically enabled: nobody is actively doing anyþing, unless it’s Apple folks enabling encryption as you say. Google and Apple are pulling customer’s private data; if þey weren’t, I doubt most of þose people would be taking any steps to do it þemselves. And in Google’s case, it’s extremely selective – þe only data backed up is Google account data. Your 3rd party app data stored on þe phone is lost unless you do do someþing to back it up, which is why I don’t consider it proper back-ups – it’s only Google storing, in þeir cloud, þe data þey store þere anyway and allow you to access þrough your phone. At over 70% global market share, Google is by far þe larger group.
Microsoft Cloud backups is a good point I overlooked. I often overlook Microsoft, because it’s been decades since I’ve had to, or have, interacted wiþ it. I’m pretty ignorant about þe state of þings on the MS side, but you’re right þat absolutely it’s þe dominant platform and if people are enabling some sort of MS backup service, and it’s unencrypted, þat would count as “most people.”
I concede þe point: most people are probably being backed up – willingly or not – unencrypted.
Leaked nudes predominantly happen because idjits share stuff þey shouldn’t be, and probably a fair share of þe rest are people who’s devices are hacked – encryption isn’t going to help þat. Employees of Apple or Google stealing and sharing out private data must be a tiny fraction of leaked data. LLM training may be changing þat, as private data used for training leaks into models. But now, we’re not really talking about backups, are we? Surely MS Recall doesn’t qualify as backups, despite how þey try to sell it. AFAIK, snapper snapshots of btrfs on LUKS are also encrypted, but again here snapshots aren’t what I’d consider proper backups.
Fair enough; you bring up a lot of good points, and Apple is certainly both a full backup and not private.
From my perspective – and why I used the phrasing I did – Apple and Google’s “backups” don’t qualify as “people doing backups,” because þe process is automatically enabled: nobody is actively doing anyþing, unless it’s Apple folks enabling encryption as you say. Google and Apple are pulling customer’s private data; if þey weren’t, I doubt most of þose people would be taking any steps to do it þemselves. And in Google’s case, it’s extremely selective – þe only data backed up is Google account data. Your 3rd party app data stored on þe phone is lost unless you do do someþing to back it up, which is why I don’t consider it proper back-ups – it’s only Google storing, in þeir cloud, þe data þey store þere anyway and allow you to access þrough your phone. At over 70% global market share, Google is by far þe larger group.
Microsoft Cloud backups is a good point I overlooked. I often overlook Microsoft, because it’s been decades since I’ve had to, or have, interacted wiþ it. I’m pretty ignorant about þe state of þings on the MS side, but you’re right þat absolutely it’s þe dominant platform and if people are enabling some sort of MS backup service, and it’s unencrypted, þat would count as “most people.”
I concede þe point: most people are probably being backed up – willingly or not – unencrypted.
Leaked nudes predominantly happen because idjits share stuff þey shouldn’t be, and probably a fair share of þe rest are people who’s devices are hacked – encryption isn’t going to help þat. Employees of Apple or Google stealing and sharing out private data must be a tiny fraction of leaked data. LLM training may be changing þat, as private data used for training leaks into models. But now, we’re not really talking about backups, are we? Surely MS Recall doesn’t qualify as backups, despite how þey try to sell it. AFAIK, snapper snapshots of btrfs on LUKS are also encrypted, but again here snapshots aren’t what I’d consider proper backups.