• Dasus@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    11 months ago

    Lol at you attempting to paint me as someone denying israels genocide in palestine. Sheer desperation from you here.

    Ah, so you accept the reality, which is that Israel is committing a genocide? You’ll readily accept that fact, and won’t try to dodge the question or pretend there isn’t a genocide?

    Good.

    I’d tell you you need to watch your projection. Youre feeling extremely ashamed, that’s why you’re talking about desperation. Because you despaired when you realised how wrong you are, from the votes and everyone explaining to you what “prescriptive” and “descriptive” mean. You didn’t understand it.

    So now you’re trying to appeal to authority while not even making an argument. Desperately. You think that link seems authoritative. The EU discussing how antisemitism is defined doesn’t change that using nazi doesn’t make you antisemitic, and it doesn’t change the fact that “nazi” is synonymous with “fascist”, so calling Israeli soldiers nazis is not linguistically erroneous.

    Defining “nazi” prescriptively as having one single meaning would be linguistically erroneus. Which you will never admit to.

    So which part in this EU link which I did actually read through is supposed to say that descriptive rules for a language have gone out the window?

    Or is it now the comparison between Israel and Nazi Germany policies that you’re saying is antisemitic, and not the colloquial use of “nazi”? Because those aren’t the same thing?

    Don’t be so desperate, you can get out of all this shame simply by not replying. No more humiliation for you, it can all be over. Just lie back and take it.

    • undergroundoverground@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      11 months ago

      Wow, you really have some issues you need to work out there. You really went and rage typed all that didn’t you?

      No, I don’t care that I get downvoted for saying that people shouldn’t call Jewish people, regardless of whether they’re referred to as Israelis or, not nazis. I also didn’t say that you or anyone here is an antisemitic person. My point is that the action of doing so is. If I thought you genuinely wanted to be antisemitic, I wouldn’t bother telling you now would I?

      I love, love how you start off taking about projection and then lost a whole load of emotions that you feel I’m feeling, without a hint of irony.

      The part of the equality and human rights commission that says:

      Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis

      Specifically.

      Again, if you’re just referring to them in the way you would call someone, say, a grammar nazi, why do you HAVE to keep saying it? Why do you feel the need to defend it so vigorously?

      Come one now, grow a spine and answer.